In the Town of Smithtown, an open permit is a building permit that was issued but never finished with a certificate of occupancy or certificate of compliance, and the Town Building Department is the office that can confirm it. The Department will search its files to see whether every permit on a property has a certificate, and work done without a permit has none. Here is how that works for Smithtown homes on both sides of a sale.
TL;DR
- The Town of Smithtown Building Department searches its files to see whether every permit on a property has a CO or certificate of compliance.
- Permits expire one year after issue and can be renewed once for half the original fee; after that, a new application is needed.
- Houses built before 1947 can get a History Letter (Letter in Lieu) for $500, with a recent survey and an exterior inspection.
- Decks over 8 inches high, fences over four feet, larger sheds, pools, and finished basements all need permits, according to the Town.
- The Village of the Branch, Nissequogue, and Head of the Harbor run their own building departments.
Table of contents
- What counts as an open permit in Smithtown
- Which office holds the file
- Common items that need a permit
- How a permit gets closed out
- Houses built before 1947
- What open permits mean for a sale
- How I handle permit items
- Next steps for a specific address
What counts as an open permit in Smithtown
Two different gaps get called "open permits." The first is a permit that was issued but never reached its final inspection and certificate. The second is work that never had a permit at all. The Town's Building Department questions page says the Department will search its files to see whether all permits have certificates, and that "any work done without permits will not have a certificate." Reviewing the files carries no charge, according to the same page, and an official copy of a CO or certificate of compliance with a raised seal costs $50 on the Town's duplicate CO and History Letter request form.
Which office holds the file
Smithtown addresses outside the incorporated villages fall under the Town Building Department. The exception is the three incorporated villages. The Town's village building departments page says the Smithtown Building Department "does not accept applications for projects within the Village of the Branch, Village of Nissequogue or Head of the Harbor," because those villages have their own departments. Head of the Harbor and Nissequogue both list St. James mailing addresses there, so a Saint James address can sit in the Town or in a village, and the tax map, not the mailing address, settles which office holds the permits.
Common items that need a permit
The Town's Building Department answers list these permit thresholds, which come up often on older houses:
- Decks more than 8 inches above the natural or approved grade at any point.
- Fences over four feet high.
- Sheds over 144 square feet and 12 feet tall; other accessory structures over 50 square feet.
- Pools that can hold more than 24 inches of water.
- Finished basements, which the Town ties to ceiling height, smoke detector, egress, light, and ventilation requirements.
- Roofline changes, new gables, widened window openings, and all skylights. Simple re-shingling does not need a permit.
A finished basement, a backyard deck, and an above-ground pool are the kinds of items that show up on a house but not on the file.
How a permit gets closed out
A permit closes when the work passes inspection and the Department issues a CO or certificate of compliance. Timing matters. The Town's questions page says a permit "is good of one year from date of issue and may be renewed for one year only," and the residential fee schedule, revised June 3, 2026, sets the renewal at half the original fee. After that, the schedule treats any further permit as a new application at current fees. Each inspection category includes two inspections, and each additional one is $50. The schedule calls its figures approximate and points owners to the Department for an exact fee.
The Town's online permit portal covers many residential projects, from decks and pools to tank removals. Once a permit is issued, an owner can check its status, view certificates, and schedule inspections online. Work that never had a permit goes through a new application, with plans and inspections like any other job.
Houses built before 1947
Smithtown did not require building permits before 1947, according to the Town's Building Department answers, so an older house may have no CO for its original structure. For those homes the Department issues a History Letter, also called a Letter in Lieu. The request form lists the requirements: a survey from the last five years, assessor's documents (obtained by the Department), a smoke alarm and carbon monoxide detector affidavit, and an exterior inspection by the Department. The fee is $500. Anything added after 1947 still needs its own permit and certificate.
What open permits mean for a sale
For sellers
An open or missing permit does not erase itself at closing. The buyer's attorney and title company typically review municipal paperwork, and an item found late can push a closing date or turn into a negotiation. A Building Department search before listing shows what the file says while there is still time to schedule inspections, renew a permit, or file for work that was never permitted. The seller consultation is where that fits into listing prep.
For buyers
A buyer can compare what the house has with what the file shows. A finished basement or a pool that is not on the file is a question for the inspection and attorney review, not something to sort out after closing. The buyer consultation covers how that fits into an offer. Tax questions for the same address are in Smithtown property taxes.
How I handle permit items
Smithtown is my main market, along with Hauppauge and Saint James. When a permit item needs work before a listing or a closing, I bring in an expediter I have worked with before, along with the attorneys and loan officer on the deal. When a client is selling one home and buying another, I run both sides at the same time, so a permit question on either house comes up early instead of at the closing table.
Next steps for a specific address
The first step for any address is the Building Department file search. From there, owners can start with a seller consultation and buyers with a buyer consultation.
More about me.