Selling one Smithtown house and buying another at the same time means two contracts, two closings, and one move that has to line up. The dates live in the two contracts, so the paperwork on each house sets the pace. Here is how it works for Smithtown homes, and the same state rules apply in Hauppauge and Saint James.
TL;DR
- New York sellers deliver a property condition disclosure statement before the buyer signs a binding contract; the $500 credit option was struck by a 2023 law.
- The seller generally pays the state transfer tax of $2 for each $500 of consideration, filed on Form TP-584.
- Fannie Mae accepts a bridge loan as a source of funds if it is not cross-collateralized against the new home.
- The Town Building Department will search its files to see whether every permit on a house has a certificate.
- A STAR exemption does not transfer to a newly purchased home; the new home gets a STAR credit after registering.
Table of contents
- One move, two contracts
- The sale side: disclosure and transfer tax
- The purchase side: financing the overlap
- Both houses: the Town file and STAR
- How I run a sell and buy
- Related pages
One move, two contracts
A sell and buy has one hard question: which closing happens first. Sale first means the move needs somewhere to land. Purchase first means carrying two houses for a stretch. The answer comes from the numbers and the dates both contracts allow, not from a rule of thumb. What can be settled early is the paperwork, because every item below can be checked before either house goes to contract.
The sale side: disclosure and transfer tax
Property condition disclosure
Under the Property Condition Disclosure Act in Real Property Law section 462, the seller of a house with one to four units delivers a property condition disclosure statement to the buyer or buyer's agent before the buyer signs a binding contract of sale. Assembly bill A1967, signed September 22, 2023 as Chapter 484, struck the $500 credit that sellers once gave instead of the form, and added flood questions: whether the property sits in a 100-year or 500-year floodplain on FEMA maps and its flood insurance history. The statute's definition leaves out condominium units and cooperative apartments.
State transfer tax
The NYS Tax Department's transfer tax page sets the rate at $2 for each $500 of consideration, paid by the seller, unless the contract or an exemption says otherwise. Outside New York City, Form TP-584 is filed with the county clerk no later than the 15th day after the deed is delivered. A residence at $1 million or more also carries an additional 1% tax, which the buyer pays.
The purchase side: financing the overlap
When the purchase closes before the sale, some buyers look at a bridge, or swing, loan. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide treats a bridge loan as an acceptable source of funds when it is not cross-collateralized against the new property and the lender documents the borrower's ability to carry the payments for the new home, the current home, the bridge loan and other obligations. Whether a given lender offers one, and on what terms, is a question for the loan officer.
Both houses: the Town file and STAR
The Town of Smithtown Building Department answers say the Department will search its files to see whether all permits have certificates, with no charge to review the files. Work done without a permit has no certificate, and a house built before 1947, when permits were not yet required, can get a History Letter. The Town's village building departments page adds that the Village of the Branch, Nissequogue and Head of the Harbor run their own departments.
On taxes, the Tax Department's STAR FAQs say STAR exemptions cannot be transferred to newly purchased homes. The new home gets a STAR credit after registering, and the owner on July 1 decides eligibility for the year.
How I run a sell and buy
When I represent the same owner on the sale and the purchase, I run both sides at once, so a question on either house comes up early. On the sale side, I stage the home myself: decor, plants and accessories, then my cleaning crew, then professional photos. Around the deal, I bring in attorneys, a loan officer and an expediter I have worked with before. Smithtown is my main market, with Hauppauge and Saint James.
Related pages
More about me.