New York's seller disclosure form asks about the flood map and about flood history in separate questions, and the two answers do not have to match. A house outside FEMA's high-risk zone can still need a yes on the water questions, which matters for Smithtown homes after the Town of Smithtown's nor'easter update of September 26, 2026 reported live street-camera monitoring at known flood-prone roadways and coastal flooding at the Town marina.
The Town's weekend nor'easter advisory of September 25, 2026 warned of prolonged heavy rain, coastal flooding and localized flooding. A storm like that does not redraw a FEMA map. It can change what a seller knows, and the disclosure form is answered from the seller's actual knowledge.
Which flood map applies to a Smithtown house
Chapter 168 of the Smithtown Town Code, Flood Damage Prevention, adopted August 11, 2009 as Local Law No. 4-2009, names 18 FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Map panels for the Town of Smithtown, community number 360810, with an effective date of September 25, 2009. Section 168-6 says the maps and the Suffolk County flood study are on file at the Planning Department in Town Hall Annex Building 2 on Redwood Lane.
FEMA's Flood Map Service Center describes itself as the official public source for flood hazard information under the National Flood Insurance Program, and it notes that maps are updated and can be superseded over time. What that means at a sale: the panel number and effective date are part of the answer. The address search on the FEMA site shows the panel in effect on the day it is run.
For a first look before that search, the site's flood zone check runs an address.
What a Special Flood Hazard Area triggers
FEMA's flood zone glossary defines the Special Flood Hazard Area as land that a flood with a 1-percent chance of being equaled or exceeded in any given year would cover, the base flood or 100-year flood. Those areas carry zone labels that start with A or V, and two separate things follow when a Smithtown house sits inside one.
The first is the loan. FEMA's questions and answers for real estate professionals, dated August 2025, says lenders require flood insurance inside the Special Flood Hazard Area when the loan on the building is government-backed, that some lenders require it outside as well, and that understanding the lender's requirement before the purchase prevents delays at closing.
The second is construction. Under section 168-12, development in the Special Flood Hazard Area needs a floodplain development permit, granted or denied by the Director of Planning as the Town's local administrator, with an application fee of $2 per square foot of gross floor area and a deposit of up to $500 for added review costs. Section 168-20 bars occupying new or altered space there until the Town issues a certificate of compliance.
For a buyer, the loan piece arrives first and costs money every year. For a seller, the construction piece matters if past work in the zone never received that certificate.
The wider permit file is covered in Smithtown open permits.
The flood questions on the seller's disclosure
The Department of State's Property Condition Disclosure Statement (form DOS-1614-f, Rev. 02/25) groups eight flood questions together:
- 10: any part of the property in a FEMA designated floodplain
- 11: any part in the Special Flood Hazard Area on FEMA's current flood insurance rate maps
- 12: any part in a Moderate Risk Flood Hazard Area, the 500-year floodplain
- 13: any requirement under federal law to obtain and maintain flood insurance
- 14: federal disaster flood assistance received by the seller or known to have gone to a previous owner
- 15: flood insurance on the property
- 16: a FEMA elevation certificate available
- 17: a claim for flood damage filed with any insurer, including the National Flood Insurance Program
The seller delivers the form to the buyer or the buyer's agent before the buyer signs a binding contract of sale.
The 2023 law that put these questions on the form is covered in selling and buying in Smithtown at once.
Question 14 is the one that changes a buyer's costs for years. The form's own note says that when a property has received federal disaster assistance, the requirement to obtain flood insurance passes down to all future owners. That obligation follows the house, not the person who took the aid. A seller who knows of assistance paid after an earlier storm, even to a prior owner, helps the sale by writing it down plainly.
Questions 38 and 39 after the September storm
These two ask what happened on the property, not what the map shows. Question 38 asks whether flooding, drainage or grading problems resulted in standing water on any portion of the property, and asks for the locations. Question 39 asks whether the structure has had water penetration or damage due to seepage or a natural flood event, such as heavy rainfall, coastal storm surge, tidal inundation or river overflow.
The form warns that a knowingly false or incomplete statement may subject the seller to claims by the buyer before or after the transfer of title. Its certification adds that a seller who acquires knowledge making an earlier statement materially inaccurate delivers a revised statement to the buyer as soon as practicable, up to the transfer of title or the buyer's occupancy, whichever is earlier.
For a Smithtown seller, that makes late September 2026 a reason to reread questions 38 and 39 even if the form was signed in the summer. Water in a basement during the storm is now actual knowledge. A yes with the date, the location and what was done gives a buyer a fact to weigh; a water line found at inspection next to a no on the form raises exactly the issue the form's warning describes.
When Smithtown's flood rules reach an older house
Both of the Smithtown houses I have sold were built in the 1960s, one in 1963 and one in 1964, more than four decades before the Town adopted Chapter 168. The chapter's elevation standards apply to new construction and to substantially improved structures in the Special Flood Hazard Area, not to a house simply because it is old.
Section 168-4 defines substantial improvement as reconstruction, rehabilitation, an addition or other improvement costing 50% or more of the market value of the structure before the work starts, and it counts a house with substantial damage the same way, regardless of the repair work actually done.
Once a project crosses that line in Zones A1-A30, AE or AH, section 168-24 has the bottom floor, basement included, elevated to two feet or more above the base flood elevation. Section 168-21 has the Town keep the certified as-built floor elevations it collects for new and substantially improved buildings. A 1960s house that was never reworked under the chapter may have nothing on file, which is why question 16 on the form often depends on the seller's own papers.
For a buyer planning a large renovation on a house in an A zone, the 50% test is the figure to price before the offer.
Next steps, in order
- Run the address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center and save the panel number, the zone and the effective date.
- Compare that zone with questions 10 to 12 on the disclosure form; a zone starting with A or V is a yes on question 11.
- Read questions 14 and 17 together: a yes on 14 carries a flood insurance requirement to every future owner, and 17 shows whether a flood claim was filed.
- Look for an elevation certificate in the seller's papers first, then ask the Town's floodplain manager, the Director of Planning, as FEMA's elevation certificate page suggests.
- For a seller, update questions 38 and 39 for the September 2026 storm before the form goes to a buyer, and deliver a revised form if anything changes after that.
- For a buyer with a government-backed loan in an A or V zone, get the lender's flood insurance requirement in writing before signing the contract.
- For planned work or storm repairs near half the structure's value, ask the Planning Department about a floodplain development permit before design starts.