NYS Housing and Anti-Discrimination Notice Mobile: (631) 252-5301 Signature Premier Properties, 7 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787, Office: (631) 360-2800
Jamie DelCore Licensed Real Estate Salesperson, Signature Premier Properties Signature Premier Properties

Smithtown, New York · Seller's guide

Selling Your Home in Smithtown, NY

Thinking of selling your Smithtown home? You've got the same four things on your mind as everybody else: what's it worth, what do I actually have to fix, what's this going to cost me, and who can I trust with it.

I'm Jamie DelCore. I sell homes in Smithtown, and all over Long Island, as a Licensed Real Estate Salesperson at Signature Premier Properties. I was born and raised in Smithtown, I'm on the Hauppauge football board and I'm involved in Hauppauge lacrosse. So you'll get the answers I'd give someone I'm going to run into around town, including the ones you may not love.

Who you'd be calling

Why Smithtown sellers call me.

Born and raised in Smithtown

It's home, it's where my office is, and Smithtown is part of the ground I cover. More about me.

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

License 10401350898, State of New York. Licensed since 2020.

Signature Premier Properties

Licensed Real Estate Broker. The office is at 7 West Main Street, Smithtown. Office: (631) 360-2800. Mobile: (631) 252-5301.

Hauppauge football board

I'm on the board, and I'm involved in Hauppauge lacrosse too. These are people I keep seeing, and I like it that way.

11 homes sold, 10 above asking

Ten of the 11 homes I've sold for their owners went for more than the list price. Take a look.

I walk your Smithtown house myself

Nobody gets sent in my place. I want to see it with my own eyes before I say a number out loud.

Comfortable with older houses

Nearly every home I've sold was built between 1950 and 1978, so I know what buyers worry about in a house with some miles on it.

October 2026, where things stand

What is happening in Smithtown right now.

28Homes sold in October
37Median days on market
$830,000Median sale price
306Homes sold, last 12 months
100.40%Sale price against asking

Data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID as of October 2026. Read several months together before you draw a conclusion. More on Smithtown.

How I read these numbers

Yes, the market cooled off this fall. The typical sale took 14 days in June, 16 in August, 21 in September and 37 in October. Buyers went from paying about 105 percent of asking in July to about 100 percent now.

Before you decide that means you should wait, look at what happened after this same slowdown a year ago. In October and November of 2025, buyers were paying right at asking and homes were taking about 28 days. Then December came in at nearly 102 percent. By January it was over 103 percent, and nine out of ten homes that closed went at or above asking. February was the one weak spot, at under 99 percent. March was back to 13 days and almost 103 percent.

Part of that is timing, since a January closing is usually a deal somebody made back in the fall. Still, Smithtown buyers didn't vanish last winter.

One warning: don't use August to price your house. The median that month hit $994,500 because the houses that sold were larger, about 2,498 square feet at the median. One month later it was $815,000. And supply has shifted. In August, 40 homes closed against 33 new listings. In October, 28 closed and 29 came on. Buyers aren't running short of houses the way they were in the summer, which is why price matters more right now.

None of this prices your house. It tells us how buyers are behaving. Your block, your roof and your layout are a separate conversation, and that's the one I'd rather have with you in person.

What buyers will pay

What is your home really worth?

Nearly everyone who calls opens with some version of "I might sell my home in Smithtown, so what would it go for?" You've already looked it up online. Everybody does. Those estimates are fine for ballpark curiosity, but they're doing math on public data, and public data has no idea whether your basement is finished nicely or finished badly.

What works is a lot less exciting. I come over and walk the whole house. Then we sit down with recent sales of homes that really are like yours, what they closed at and not what they were asking for, and I show you why I land where I land. Don't take my word on any of it. You'll see the sales yourself.

When we're done, I want you holding three numbers instead of one:

  • Where I'd list it. The number that puts your home in front of the most people who could really buy it.
  • Where I think it'll end up. That's my honest opinion, and an opinion is all it is, because the buyers decide.
  • What you'd actually take home. After the mortgage, the commission, the attorney and the transfer tax. That's the one that matters to your life.

I won't say a big number just to win your listing. You'd feel great for about three weeks, and then you'd find out what the number should have been, the hard way. If you want a rough idea before we talk, ask for a valuation here. I'd still want to come see it.

What I'm comparing when I look at sales

  • How fresh the sale is. A house that closed in July, when buyers here were paying about 105 percent of asking, isn't the same evidence as one that closed in October.
  • Size above ground, then what's below. A finished basement helps, but buyers and appraisers don't treat it like living space upstairs.
  • The updates you can see and the ones you can't. A new kitchen photographs well. A new furnace doesn't, but the inspector will be glad to meet it.
  • The layout. A split level, a cape and a ranch can have identical square footage and draw completely different buyers.
  • The road out front. Traffic is one of those things buyers can't unhear once they've stood in the yard.
  • The monthly number. Buyers think in mortgage plus taxes. A heavy tax bill quietly lowers what they can pay you.
  • Who you're up against. Whatever else is listed in your range the day you go live is your real competition.

Taxes deserve a real look here. A home I sold in Smithtown in September carried about $11,798 a year, which is about $983 a month before the buyer has made a single mortgage payment. I'd want to know your actual bill before we pick a price. Taxes have been on people's minds around here lately, so I wrote about what the tax-cap override means for homeowners.

What about listing high and seeing what happens?

It feels free. It isn't. Buyers shop inside a range on their phones. If somebody's limit is $800,000 and you list at $815,000, you don't get a lower offer from them. You just don't exist to them. And the people who do see it are comparing you to better houses. Overprice it and you'll spend your first few weeks being the house people use to justify buying a different house.

And listing low to start a frenzy?

I understand why that's tempting. It can work when plenty of buyers are out and the house is one they really want. But if only one person shows up, that low number is what you're negotiating from. I'd want to see what's happening that exact month before I'd suggest it.

The appraisal comes after the excitement

Say a buyer offers well over your list price and they're getting a mortgage. The lender sends an appraiser, and if the appraiser can't support that number with other sales, the bank lends on the lower figure. Then somebody covers the difference, the price comes down, or the deal ends. So before you say yes to a big number, I want to know how that buyer would handle a short appraisal.

Want a real number for your house?

Even if you aren't moving anytime soon, it's a good thing to know.

Have me come take a look

Getting it ready

How I'd get your home ready.

Selling a home in Smithtown starts well before the sign goes up, and I'd ask you not to spend a dime until I've walked it with you. You've lived there so long that your eyes skip right over the cords, the laundry basket and the pile on the stairs. A buyer's eyes won't. I'll tell you what I see, and I've got no problem telling you that the giant sectional makes the den look like a closet.

Most people's instinct is to start with the most expensive thing in the house. I'd start with the cheapest.

Get the stuff out

This costs you almost nothing but a few weekends, and nothing else you do will change the house as much. Take half of what's in your closets out of the house, because people open them, and a stuffed closet says there isn't enough room. Take the wall of personal photos down for now. Clear the garage enough that someone can walk through it and imagine a car. Rent a storage unit for the season if you have to. You're moving anyway, so this is just packing early.

Have it cleaned once, properly

Pay someone who does it for a living, one time, top to bottom. Grout, shower glass, inside the oven, the windows. And take care of smells you've stopped noticing. If you've got pets or a damp basement, ask a friend what the place smells like. Or ask me. I'll tell you.

Brighten it up

Houses from the '50s and '60s can run small and dim. Open every shade, take down anything heavy on the windows, swap the tired bulbs so they all match, and paint the one dark room that bothers you. Paint is cheap help.

Finish the repairs you already paid for

A stain on the ceiling from a leak that got fixed four years ago still reads as a leak, so paint it. Same with a patch on the wall that never got sanded or the floorboard that still gives. You solved the problem. Make it look solved, or a buyer will spend the whole showing wondering what else is wet.

Where I'd put your money, in this order

  1. Anything leaking, sparking or broken. Before the photographer comes, not after.
  2. Anything that looks ignored. Wobbly railings, gutters hanging off the back, a front walk nobody's edged in years.
  3. The little stuff. The door that sticks, the running toilet, the cabinet that won't close. One of them is nothing. A whole house of them tells a story you don't want told.
  4. Lighter walls, and floors if they need it. If there's hardwood under that carpet, it's often worth finding out.
  5. Kitchens and baths, almost never. Dated and clean is fine. Plenty of buyers plan to redo it their own way and would rather not pay for your version. A full gut means you're guessing what somebody else wants, with your own money.

The big-ticket tally

Buyers run a mental list: roof, heating system, oil tank, electric panel, cesspool or septic, windows. If you've replaced any of those, go find the paperwork now, because a dated receipt is worth more than a sentence in the listing. If you haven't, we don't necessarily replace them. Generally it makes more sense to account for age in the price, knowing the buyer is doing the same math.

What a buyer is really asking

Somebody walking through your house is doing arithmetic and daydreaming at the same time. Will my stuff fit here? What's this going to run me in the first five years? What aren't they telling me? All of the above is about answering those before anybody says them out loud. A buyer who stops worrying starts mentally moving in, and that's when offers get written.

Loose ends

Any deck, dormer or finished basement you've added over the years should be signed off before a buyer's attorney asks, and this guide tells you what to do if something was left open. And if your home was built before 1978, there's a federal lead paint disclosure the buyer has to get before they're bound to buy. It's only a form, and your attorney and I will see that it's handled.

If you'd rather not do any of it

Then don't. Selling a house as it stands is a legitimate choice, and I'm not going to make you feel bad about it. Plenty of buyers want a project. The price just has to be honest about what they're getting, and the disclosure form still has to be answered truthfully.

Is it worth fixing up, or should you just sell it?

I'll tell you after I've seen it, and I won't sugarcoat it.

Have me walk it with you

Photos and showings

Getting it in front of the right buyers.

Your first showing happens on somebody's phone, probably while they're half watching something else. They'll give each listing a couple of seconds. That's why your home gets professional photos, and why I care about what's in them.

Before the shoot, walk through with your own phone and take your own pictures. It sounds silly and it works. You'll see what your eyes have been skipping for years.

Photo day, room by room

  • Kitchen: nothing on the counters except maybe one thing that looks nice. Fridge door cleared off.
  • Bathrooms: lids down, bottles out of the shower, fresh towels.
  • Bedrooms: beds made tight, nightstands bare, chargers out of sight.
  • Living areas: remotes and pet stuff put away, and every lamp on. Take out one chair or one end table per room and see how it feels.
  • Outside: garbage cans out of view, driveway empty, grass cut, front door looking good. That's the shot people judge.

Your listing goes up once

Price set, photos done, house clean, description written, showing plan agreed. When all of that lands on the same day, everyone who's been refreshing their search sees your home at its strongest. When a listing goes up half finished and then keeps getting changed, buyers notice that too. We go live when everything's ready, and not before.

Showings without losing your mind

Tell me your schedule, your dog's schedule and anything you need me to work around. Then try to be somewhere else when people come through. Buyers get quiet and polite when the owner's standing there, and quiet and polite doesn't sell anything. They need to be able to open the closets and say out loud that the bedroom's small. Afterward I'll tell you what they said, including the parts you won't love hearing.

Reading the offers

The highest offer isn't always the one you want.

Everybody looks at the same line first. I'm looking at how likely each one is to actually make it to closing. Price is the first thing you'll see, and it might be the least reliable thing on the page. A big number that falls apart six weeks in, after you've told the movers, is worse than a slightly smaller one that closes.

What I lay out next to the price, every time

  • Has a lender actually reviewed this buyer? Real documents behind a pre-approval mean a lot more than a quick pre-qualification.
  • What's the down payment? It tells you how much cushion the deal has if something comes up short.
  • Is there a home they have to sell first? If yes, your closing now depends on some stranger's house selling too.
  • What are they planning to inspect? And are they the type who'll be back asking for a credit on every line of the report?
  • When can they close? A great price on a date that doesn't work isn't a great offer for you.

I'll line them up and say which one I'd take and why. Then it's your call, because it's your house.

If more than one buyer wants it

It feels great for about an hour. Then you have to actually choose. Usually we set a deadline and ask everyone for their strongest terms by that time, so nobody's guessing and you're not answering offers one at a time. Then I go through them line by line. Sometimes the offer that's a little lower with a clean timeline is the one that gets you where you're going.

When the inspection report shows up

Expect a thick one. An inspector can write three pages on a house that's in fine shape for its age. Most of it is small. What deserves a real conversation is anything about water, the roof, the heating system or the sewage system.

When a buyer comes back with a list, you've got four choices: fix it, give a credit, come down a little or say no. I'm usually thinking about one question. Would the next buyer's inspector find the same thing? If yes, we probably deal with it now. If it's a wish list, we don't have to play along. And I'll be direct with you if I think you're fighting about something that's not worth losing a buyer over.

What comes out of your check

CommissionNegotiable. We settle it, in writing, before the listing goes live.
Your attorneyStandard for a New York sale. Ask for the fee up front when you hire them.
NY transfer taxThe state takes $2 out of each $500 of your price, and the seller normally pays it. On a sale at Smithtown's $830,000 October median, the tax comes to $3,320. See the state's rules.
Mortgage payoffWhat's left on your loan, plus any equity line, comes off at closing.
AdjustmentsProperty taxes, fuel and similar items get split between you and the buyer by date, so you could get some back.

I'd run an estimated take-home number with you early. It's a little awkward to talk about, and it's the most useful number on this page.

Want to see your take-home number?

I'll put it together with you. It takes less time than you'd think.

Get in touch

The home stretch

From accepted offer to closing.

Selling a home in Smithtown doesn't end when you shake hands on a price. An accepted offer is the start, and nothing's binding until there's a signed contract. Here's the usual order on Long Island:

  1. Attorneys get going. Yours writes up the contract and theirs reviews it. Have yours lined up before you're in a hurry.
  2. The buyer's inspection. It generally wraps up before anybody signs, and the back-and-forth happens here.
  3. The forms. Your buyer gets New York's property condition disclosure form before signing, and the federal lead paint form on a pre-1978 home. Answer from what you really know.
  4. Signed contract and a deposit. The deposit sits in your attorney's escrow account.
  5. The bank. Appraisal and loan commitment. Often the slowest part, and it's when I'm following up the most.
  6. Title. A title company makes sure nothing is attached to the property that needs clearing up.
  7. Walk-through, closing, keys. One more look by the buyer, everybody signs, and your proceeds get paid out.

I'd hold off on giving the movers a date until the contract's signed and the mortgage is moving. Dates in a New York contract usually read "on or about," which means they can slip.

Real life

When it isn't simple.

People rarely sell because the numbers look nice. Usually something in their life moved first. Here's how I'd start with the ones that come up the most.

You inherited the house

Go slowly. First question: who has legal authority to sign? Talk to the estate's attorney, because that answer controls your timeline. Until then, keep the insurance and utilities current and don't throw anything out in a rush. The house doesn't have to be empty before we talk. Take the photos off the wall when you're ready, and get help with the rest.

It's time for less house

Start with one closet. Seriously. Know where you're headed before you pick a date, so the moving truck isn't chasing you. I'd rather help you do this at a pace you can live with than have you rushing through your own life.

You're selling one and buying the next

One question decides most of it: do you need the money from this house to buy the next one? Answer that with a lender before anything else. From there you sell first, buy first, or line up the two closings, and each one has a catch we'd go through together. Alexandria Clervoix did both with me and wrote, "She helped us handle both." I also wrote a guide to selling and buying around Smithtown that goes through the financing and timing.

You've already moved away

You don't have to be here. I can get people in, keep an eye on the place and keep you posted, and your attorney can explain signing from wherever you've landed. Keep the heat on in winter and don't let the insurance slide on an empty house.

You've got second thoughts

Tell me. It's a big decision, and getting nervous about it is completely normal. I'd rather you pull back than do something you regret, and I'm not going to argue you out of how you feel.

From people I've worked with

What my sellers say.

"Jamie was wonderful! Super down to earth and personable, made the sale of our house easy and calm. She also kept us on the loop every step of the way."

Mike and John, July 2026

"She was attentive, informative and well spoken. Jamie made the process as smooth, fast, and uncomplicated and stress free as possible."

Alexandria Clervoix, October 2026

Recent work

Homes I've sold.

A 1963 Smithtown home, about 1,313 square feet

It went on at $679,000 and closed at $751,000 in September 2026.

Every one of them is on my sold homes page, and there's more about the town on my Smithtown page.

Ask away

What Smithtown sellers ask me.

Straight answers to the usual ones.

Who should sell my home in Smithtown?

Let me make my case. I'm Jamie DelCore, a Licensed Real Estate Salesperson at Signature Premier Properties, and 10 of the 11 homes I've sold for their owners went above asking. Every house gets walked by me, in person, before any number comes out of my mouth. Call me on my Mobile, (631) 252-5301, and let's talk about yours.

How fast could my Smithtown home sell?

The typical Smithtown sale in October spent a median of 37 days listed. June was closer to 14. Once you've accepted an offer, figure roughly two months or longer to reach the closing, with the buyer's lender and the attorneys setting most of that pace. A cash buyer can shorten it. A well-priced house moves quicker in every season.

Should I wait for spring?

Your house and your life decide that, but don't assume the winter is dead here. Last January Smithtown homes sold for over 103 percent of asking, and in March the typical home took 13 days. If you're ready, the fall isn't something to be scared of. If your house needs months of work anyway, spring's fine.

What would my Smithtown home sell for?

The $830,000 median describes the town. It knows nothing about your roof, your floor plan or your street. I'd need to walk it and pull the sales that really compare, and then you'll see exactly how I got to the number.

How much should I spend getting ready?

Tell me what you're comfortable with, including nothing. At zero we clean, clear out and price it correctly. With a little money, I'd go after small repairs and fresh paint where it's needed. You almost certainly don't need a new kitchen, and you rarely get a remodel's cost back when you sell right after. I'd rather help you spend less and spend it in the right rooms.

Can I sell without fixing anything?

You can. You'll still have to answer truthfully about what you're aware of, and the price has to match the condition. Some buyers go hunting for a house just like that. What doesn't work is pretending the problems aren't there, because the inspector's going to find them.

Should I get an inspection before I list?

Sometimes. On an older house it can be worth it if there's something you're honestly unsure about, so you aren't learning about it from the buyer's report. If nothing's bothering you, it's usually not needed. Show me when I'm there and we'll decide.

Do I have to be home for showings?

No, and I'd encourage you not to be. You can keep your distance the entire time the house is on the market, as long as we've agreed on when and how people get in.

If I get an offer over asking, should I just take it?

Look at what's behind it first. How strong is the financing, how would they cover a short appraisal, what do they plan to inspect, and when can they close? We'll weigh it against whatever else you've got, and against what the next buyer would likely do.

What do I have to tell buyers about problems?

The truth, about what you know. New York's disclosure form walks through it, and your attorney can help you answer it. A problem you disclosed is a negotiation. A problem they find later is a real headache for you, and I'd much prefer to talk about it early.

Is the commission negotiable?

Yes. We'll put it in writing before anything's listed, and I'll spell out what you get for it.

Can we just talk first?

Please do. Mobile: (631) 252-5301. There's no charge and no form to fill out, and knowing your numbers doesn't commit you to anything. If you're still interviewing agents, here's what I'd ask anyone you're considering.

Next step

Curious what your Smithtown home would bring? Just ask me.

If "should I sell my home in Smithtown" has been rattling around in your head, call me. You don't need to be ready. You don't need the house clean. Tell me what's going on, I'll come by and walk it, and you'll get my honest opinion. What you do with that is up to you.

Jamie DelCore Talk to Jamie